American Nuclear Society

Home / Publications / Journals / Nuclear Technology / Volume 193 / Number 1

Content, Completeness, and Consistency of Analytical Models for Regulatory Consideration

Robert P. Martin

Nuclear Technology / Volume 193 / Number 1 / January 2016 / Pages 96-112

Technical Paper / Special Issue on the RELAP5-3D Computer Code /

First Online Publication:November 24, 2015
Updated:January 4, 2016

This paper reviews the historical and contemporary precedence regarding the development of knowledge, its reformulation in computer codes, and subsequent application in decision making. It highlights the practical challenges of this process as it applies to the investigation of engineered systems to deliver on both promised benefits and protection from postulated failures. A model for demonstrating model content, completeness, and consistency is described, invoking and extending a knowledge/content model attributed to Popper. While the specific example examining the evolution of the thermal-hydraulic knowledge base applied for nuclear power plant safety analysis and its capture in the RELAP series of computer analysis codes is presented, the framework is general, true to the scientific method, and thus broadly applicable. It concludes that while content of our knowledge base is perpetually increasing, completeness and consistency are fundamentally unattainable; however, within a well-designed evaluation methodology, measurable proof, sufficient for regulatory deliberation, is possible.

Questions or comments about the site? Contact the ANS Webmaster.