Little ado about nothing

January 3, 2012, 5:08PMANS Nuclear Cafe

A so-called scientific article issued on December 19 by Joseph Mangano and Janette Sherman purports that an estimated 14,000 excess deaths in the United States are linked to the radioactive fallout from the damaged Fukushima Daiichi nuclear reactors in Japan. The article, published in the International Journal of Health Services, is available by clicking here.

Not much media attention has been paid to the article, which has been labeled as "flawed" by the Nuclear Energy Institute. NEI, on its blog site, subsequently posted columns about the article and about Mangano, who has a history as an anti-nuclear writer. In one of the posts, NEI points out that "Mike Moyer, the writer at Scientific American who so expertly debunked Joe Mangano's 'research' in June, had a chance to read Mangano's latest coauthored piece."

Moyer wrote:

No attempt is made at providing systematic error estimates, or error estimates of any kind. No attempt is made to catalog any biases that may have crept into the analysis, though a cursory look finds biases a-plenty (the authors are anti-nuclear activists unaffiliated with any research institution). The analysis assumes that the plume arrived on U.S. shores, spread everywhere, instantly, and started killing people immediately. It assumes that the "excess" deaths after March 20 are a real signal, not just a statistical aberration, and that every one of them is due to Fukushima radiation.

Moyer went on to say:

The publication of such sloppy, agenda-driven work is a shame. Certainly radiation from Fukushima is dangerous, and could very well lead to negative health effects-even across the Pacific. The world needs to have a serious discussion about what role nuclear power should play in a power-hungry post-Fukushima world. But serious, informed, fact-based debate is a difficult enough goal to achieve without having to shout above noise like this.

Others have chimed in to debunk Mangano's junk science. You can read about it by visiting NEI's blog site here and scrolling down to the article titled "Dr. Robert Peter Gale's Statement on the Mangano-Sherman Report on Fukushima Fallout."

NEI's blog site also has other posts on the Mangano-Sherman report, which you can find by scrolling down at the site.


Related Articles

Radiation myths continue

May 13, 2021, 9:30AMANS Nuclear Cafe

Atomic fission can provide all the world’s people with as much emission-free electricity as they need for prosperity, but the cost of nuclear energy has risen due to excessive regulations...

Calming fears about low-dose radiation

March 8, 2021, 12:00PMANS News

During my time as vice president and president of ANS, I have been advocating for a new approach to implementing dose limits across the nuclear industry. A lack of understanding and an...

Farming in Fukushima

February 12, 2021, 11:57AMANS Nuclear Cafe

Vice News has published a video on YouTube that follows two farmers from the Fukushima Prefecture, Noboru Saito and Koji Furuyama. Saito, who grows many different crops on his farm, says that...